This thread is a spectacularly bad look waiting to happen.
Either that or it's wilfully dumb-as-a-brick troll bait.
Or, we could have an intelligent discourse. So, do you agree or disagree with me, and why? - Diego
DocMcCoy"Go and laugh in your own country!" 5,917 Posts
SPlDEY said:
DocMcCoy said:
This thread is a spectacularly bad look waiting to happen.
Either that or it's wilfully dumb-as-a-brick troll bait.
Or, we could have an intelligent discourse. So, do you agree or disagree with me, and why? - Diego
Dude, the premise itself is dumb as shit, so you're not exactly starting from a position of strength. "Can we move on yet?" To what, precisely? How about you make your case first? Right now, you're talking like the frontman for a Charlie Daniels cover band.
I like guitars and real drummers. I like electronic music. I like both together, sometimes. I like music that features neither guitars and real drummers nor electronics. I even like silence. As far as this topic is concerned, I think I might like silence best of all.
daphne oram
tod dokstader
robert moog
raymond scott
delia derbyshire
kid baltan and tom dissevelt
kraftwerk
80's electro
art of noise
Susan cianni
digital jamaican music
all the dub producers
detroit techno pioneers
afrika bambatta
house music in general
warp records--aphex twin squarepusher boards of canada
rephlex records
mille plateaux
ninja tune
skam???planet mu???..etc etc
all really suck and haven't pioneered anything at all-He's dead on the money!!
This thread is a spectacularly bad look waiting to happen.
Either that or it's wilfully dumb-as-a-brick troll bait.
Or, we could have an intelligent discourse. So, do you agree or disagree with me, and why? - Diego
I agree that you think it's boring, but I disagree that it is.
You know what man.. you're absolutely right. I mean.. you put up a good argument, but I completely agree that I think it's boring. At least we're on the same page.
- Diego
DocMcCoy"Go and laugh in your own country!" 5,917 Posts
SPlDEY said:
Mind you I live in Vegas. The shit's played. Have I hurt anyones feelings yet?
- spidey
The shit was played 20 years ago, right around the time a contemporaneous Sonic Youth documentary called 1991: The Year Punk Broke was released in the US. You guys might wanna get that watch looked at. I think it might be a little slow.
Seriously, this is what you're upset about? Shitty comedy rave and the dubstep equivalent of Skid Row? That's what you're calling "electronic music"? And the schoolgirl remarks about hurting people's feelings - that's the kind of "intelligent discourse" you were after?
Hi Diego,
I think you're talking about a narrow strand of music which America has christened 'EDM', ie electro-riff Euro-house music. Most people on this board are going to agree that from Tiesto to to Deadmou5 to anyone playing a wav file whilst emoting over a control surface, pointing their fingers skywayds and imploring a crowd of easy-to-please prancers on drugs to lose their shit NOW is a joke. But I reckon 75% of them would admit there's some merit to the music that whole aesthetic is derived from eg Daft Punk via Chicago house music via 80s boogie music via blah blah blah.
I personally agree that those examples you've collaged together make a convincingly hellish argument.
- Tom
I'd have to agree that the cross-section you chose to represent "electronic music" is pretty small and specific, and stuff that I mostly don't care for. However, you did open by saying "I like electric guitars and real drummers" which implies that you have a generally negative view of electronic instruments/sounds. That might not be what you meant, but that's how it comes across.
I'm personally of the opinion that if a person only likes music that's made a particular way, they don't really like music that much.
SPlDEY
Vegas 3,375 Posts
Comments
b/w
the only real, authentic, soulful music is made with rocks and sticks, caveman style.
Progress, griping, general dissent with 2012.
- spidey
Either that or it's wilfully dumb-as-a-brick troll bait.
Or, we could have an intelligent discourse. So, do you agree or disagree with me, and why? - Diego
Dude, the premise itself is dumb as shit, so you're not exactly starting from a position of strength. "Can we move on yet?" To what, precisely? How about you make your case first? Right now, you're talking like the frontman for a Charlie Daniels cover band.
I like guitars and real drummers. I like electronic music. I like both together, sometimes. I like music that features neither guitars and real drummers nor electronics. I even like silence. As far as this topic is concerned, I think I might like silence best of all.
I agree with you that electronic music bores the shit out of you because you stated so in this thread's title.
Why have discourse if youve already stated your limited opinion.
Are you looking for someone to convince you?
self-discourse, aka mental masterbation aka http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-affirmation
jazz SUCKS
and don't get me started on urban music
here are a few reasons why (embed issues)
This guy gets it. I'm gonna go get some ice cream.
- spidey
WTF is up with these synths and stuff.
Love,
SPIDEY
I agree that you think it's boring, but I disagree that it is.
I get people not being able to listen to it tho. Opinions are like assholes, everyone's got one.
daphne oram
tod dokstader
robert moog
raymond scott
delia derbyshire
kid baltan and tom dissevelt
kraftwerk
80's electro
art of noise
Susan cianni
digital jamaican music
all the dub producers
detroit techno pioneers
afrika bambatta
house music in general
warp records--aphex twin squarepusher boards of canada
rephlex records
mille plateaux
ninja tune
skam???planet mu???..etc etc
all really suck and haven't pioneered anything at all-He's dead on the money!!
This is true. You can consider CAN early electronic music. I do like Delia Derbyshire, Silver Apples, even some Kraftwerk.
I'm talking more about:
Mind you I live in Vegas. The shit's played. Have I hurt anyones feelings yet?
- spidey
You know what man.. you're absolutely right. I mean.. you put up a good argument, but I completely agree that I think it's boring. At least we're on the same page.
- Diego
The shit was played 20 years ago, right around the time a contemporaneous Sonic Youth documentary called 1991: The Year Punk Broke was released in the US. You guys might wanna get that watch looked at. I think it might be a little slow.
Seriously, this is what you're upset about? Shitty comedy rave and the dubstep equivalent of Skid Row? That's what you're calling "electronic music"? And the schoolgirl remarks about hurting people's feelings - that's the kind of "intelligent discourse" you were after?
I think you're talking about a narrow strand of music which America has christened 'EDM', ie electro-riff Euro-house music. Most people on this board are going to agree that from Tiesto to to Deadmou5 to anyone playing a wav file whilst emoting over a control surface, pointing their fingers skywayds and imploring a crowd of easy-to-please prancers on drugs to lose their shit NOW is a joke. But I reckon 75% of them would admit there's some merit to the music that whole aesthetic is derived from eg Daft Punk via Chicago house music via 80s boogie music via blah blah blah.
I personally agree that those examples you've collaged together make a convincingly hellish argument.
- Tom
I'm personally of the opinion that if a person only likes music that's made a particular way, they don't really like music that much.