Thoughts on Music Conservatories
kitchenknight
4,922 Posts
(this is going to be cross posted, so deal.)I just worked a concert for the local college music conservatory. And, I have some strong thoughts on this experience that I feel I must share. And if you went to a conservatory, and think I'm wrong, then go right ahead and tell me.But, I think music conservatory's fucking suck. Jesus. I just sat through a 2.5 hour show of seniors performing before graduation, and these fucking people had less soul and talent that most contestants on American Idol. Seriously. This was watching people who had sat through 4 years of karaoke classes. What a fucking suckhole...I'm a skeptic. Fine. But, I don't believe anyone who is going to tell me there is one right way to make music and perform. So much of what I, and it seems, we, love is music that is made in the mistakes. Songs that are not afraid to teeter on that edge, and fail. Because, the musicians and songwriters know enough about their craft and skills that they know that not every time is going to result in a plunge off the cliff--- sometimes, they hit that note, and just fucking soar.So, while a conservatory degree will probably result in some very 'nice,' and sterile music, music isn't about nice or sterile. I want trans-fucking-sendent, I want moving, I want emotion, I want dirty, I want humanity, i want soul. there. I said my piece.
Comments
They don't do mary j. blige.
Anyway I think they suck as well. Even the more liberated classes who train in "brown voices" never can bring forth any pop talent that can compete.
But I thought quicny jones was a schooled conservatory musician was he not?
But, my overall point is: you can't teach soul. and I don't mean soul the genre; i mean feeling, connection, etc.
Were these performance majors?
Now why would you go and pick a fight with bobo like that?
Nina. Simone.
Classically trained.
Miles. Davis.
Foramlly trained at Berklee.
These guys are the epitome of moving, emotionly, dirty, humanity.
Come on - expecting everyone attending a music con to have the goods is like asking all those in an off season training camp to make the grade in the NFL / NBA. It's gonna give you some skills... but's it what ya do with it, right?
I both studied and taught at a music school... and saw both sides of the argument. Some guys turned up and got bogged down in developing chops and theory - but ultimately were uninteresting in the extreme - hell a good number of the tutors were like that. Others arrived for class and you were left floored and thinking "what they hell can I teach you, you've got it...". Regardless of that the chance to spend a few years just working on your craft is pretty amazing and the exposure to new areas of music is essential.
Especially when you come into the 'real world' and there are so few opportunities to a) play whatever the hell it is you want to play and b) survive and pay the rent.
Then you end up whoring your arse in the corporate world and doing music for pure love and fun - which is exactly what I do.
4 years & masters degree a waste? Hell no.
Fair enough. This is the counter point I was looking for. And, like most things in life, it says the following:
Some folks got it. Other folks, don't.
Now, for those who you said showed up and had 'it,' was a conservatory necessary to bring that out? Or, where they wasting $$$ when they could have been out on the road?
I don't ask to antagonize- I honestly want a conversation here...
lots of incredible musicians went to conservatories. its just a place where you can focus exclusively on music. its a learning tool, nothing more. no one should expect it to be manufacturing soul.
I couldn't agree more. I've always been a little irked by people who go to college to become a poet, or go to an art school to become an artist. I feel, as with anything, you can learn a technique or a skill and be fine at it.....but if you have what it takes it will come naturally.
Some are so deprived of instinctual expression that they have to cypher it out of things they perceive as thoughtful and insightful such as art and music.
But, I dont disagree with classical training and studies.
You just got to be like the Kronos Quartet and take it beyond the realm of stagnant and boring and keep it evolving.
My father is a professor of music and a teacher at a conservatory, and he stresses the fact that people should never go there (or to any educational institution for that matter) to copy the teachers, but to LEARN from them, and then develop their own thing.
Thinking without learning creates onesidedness, and learning without thinking is a total disaster. Many talents need some form of guidance in order to reach the higher level, and a conservatory could vey well do that.
- J