little dude production question
mr.brett
678 Posts
I'm not a producer, but i've been making microwavable edits recently. I was wondering if someone could tell me how bad it is to put an mp3 into a program like sound forge and then output an mp3 when you're done with your project. Obviously it can't be good to compress an already compressed file, but i was wondering what you all thought about this issue.
Comments
technically, if you use the SAME converter that you originally compressed with to upsample with the SAME pref conversion, then you should be okay as long as you go back to the same file specs as the original.
but the chances of that happening are slim to none. so when this doesnt happen, you are basically taking an already 2nd generation file from the original source and making a 3rd generation file which for the anal retentive is .
im from the camp of, if is sounds on a system you trust, then stop in'.
______________________________________________________________
this concludes yet another dorky message from bthav.
MP3 sucks !!!!!!!
It's called adobe audition now.
What bthav is saying, is that if your editing it at all, your comp has decompressed it to wav anwyay.
Like someone mentioned earlier in the thread, whenever you open an .mp3 in any sort of audio editing app, it decodes it to a .wav. Most of the time this will be okay, but you may run into errors ocasionally. I use a combination of LAME and RazorLAME to decode MP3s before opening them in any sort of audio app and I have not run into problems in 5+ years. After that, you do your thing or whatever.
Another thing you need to watch out for is bit rate. Re-encoding MP3s is one thing, but you really do not want to change the bit rate to a higher one than it originally was. If you are using downloaded MP3s, I suggest getting "scene" releases which are just releases organized groups put out. Scene groups have encoding standards so you know the file you are working with should be decent enough to work with.
Beyond that, the only thing I can suggest is buying CD singles and work with .wav files from those or work with vinyl.